Prescribed subject 1: Military leaders
4 questions · 24 marks solved
IB HISTORY · HL AND SL · PAPER 1
Model answers for History Paper 1 (HL and SL), prescribed subjects 1, 2 and 3, written step by step in friendly handwriting: source comprehension, OPCVL analysis, comparison and the 9-mark essay.
Updated

IB History Paper 1 is the source-based paper taken by both HL and SL students. It lasts 1 hour and is worth 24 marks. Students choose one of five prescribed subjects and answer its four questions using the sources in the separate source booklet: a comprehension question, an OPCVL question, a comparison and an essay.
| Paper | Date and session | Paper code | Questions | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prescribed subject 1: Military leaders | 4 May 2026 · Afternoon | 2226-3510 | 4 | 24 |
| Prescribed subject 2: Conquest and its impact | 4 May 2026 · Afternoon | 2226-3510 | 4 | 24 |
| Prescribed subject 3: The move to global war | 4 May 2026 · Afternoon | 2226-3510 | 4 | 24 |
Paper 1 was sat on 4 May 2026 in the afternoon (all zones). Model answers are given for prescribed subjects 1, 2 and 3. The source texts are summarised in each question, so you can follow the answers.
| Command term | What you need to do |
|---|---|
| What, according to Source… | Pick out separate points stated in the source, one per mark. |
| What does Source … suggest | Infer meaning from a visual or text source, explaining what it implies. |
| Analyse value and limitations | Use origin, purpose and content to judge how useful the source is for the stated enquiry. |
| Compare and contrast | Give similarities and differences in a running, point-by-point comparison. |
| To what extent / Discuss / Examine | Build an argument using the sources and your own knowledge, then reach a judgement. |
| Code | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 3 + 2 | Question (a) rewards three explicit points; (b) rewards two inferences from the visual or text. |
| OPCVL | The 4-mark question rewards value and limitations linked to origin, purpose and content. |
| Comparison | The 6-mark question rewards linked similarities and differences, not separate summaries. |
| Essay | The 9-mark question rewards use of all relevant sources plus accurate own knowledge. |
No calculator is needed. Quote briefly from the sources, name the source each time, and support your essay with accurate dates and events.
4 questions · 24 marks solved
4 questions · 24 marks solved
4 questions · 24 marks solved
HISTORY PAPER 1 · 4 MAY 2026
Case study: Richard I of England (1173–1199), the course, outcome and effects of his campaigns. Source A (Gabriele Esposito, military historian, 2022): Richard left for England on 9 October 1192 after more than a year in the Holy Land; he had beaten the Muslims several times but could not change the political situation; a fragile peace with Saladin left the key questions unresolved; other crusader leaders saw him as a threat, and the rivalry with Philip II of France grew and led to new war in Europe. Source B: an 1848 illustration, “Crusaders and Saracens in conference”, showing mounted Christian knights and Muslims on foot talking face to face. Source C (David Hilliam, former teacher, 2004): the Battle of Jaffa was Richard’s last action and showed his skill and courage; news that his brother John was plotting with the French made him anxious to go home; Saladin also wanted peace; both leaders fell ill and exchanged gifts of fruit and medicine; the treaty of 2 September 1192 lasted three years, left Jerusalem in Muslim hands but gave Christian pilgrims free access to the holy places, Bethlehem and Nazareth, and kept the coastal cities from Tyre to Jaffa for the crusaders. Source D (Richard de Templo, 13th-century churchman, Itinerarium Peregrinorum): Saladin granted the Christians Jaffa and its surroundings; there was to be peace, free passage and access to the Holy Sepulchre and free trade; Richard asked only for a three-year truce, intending to return with money and troops to retake Jerusalem; Saladin said he admired Richard so much he would rather lose the land to him than to any other prince.
(a) What, according to Source A, were the outcomes of Richard I’s campaigns in the Middle East? [3]
(b) What does Source B suggest about the relations between Christians and Muslims in the Middle East? [2]
Answer:Any three: Richard defeated the Muslims on several occasions; he failed to change the political situation in the Middle East as he hoped; only a fragile peace with Saladin was made, leaving key questions unresolved; the rivalry with Philip II grew and led to renewed war in Europe.
Answer:Two of: they could meet and negotiate peacefully (a conference, not a battle); relations were not only hostile; the Christians appear dominant (mounted, armed) while the Muslims approach on foot, suggesting an unequal relationship.
With reference to its origin, purpose and content, analyse the value and limitations of Source D for an historian studying the outcomes of Richard I’s campaigns in the Middle East.
Analyse the value and limitations of Source D. [4]
Answer:Value: a near-contemporary Christian chronicle giving the truce terms and Richard’s intentions. Limitation: written to glorify Richard, one-sided and may exaggerate (e.g. Saladin’s admiration).
Watch out: Link each value or limitation to origin, purpose or content: do not just list OPCVL headings.
Compare and contrast what Sources A and C reveal about the participation of Richard I in the campaigns in the Middle East.
Compare and contrast Sources A and C. [6]
Answer:Both praise Richard’s courage and military skill, record the peace with Saladin, and connect his departure to problems in Europe involving France. A emphasises the limits of his achievement, while C emphasises the treaty’s gains and Saladin’s own wish for peace.
Watch out: Aim for a running comparison (point by point), with at least two similarities and two differences, each supported by the sources.
“Richard I had not been able to change the political situation of the Middle East as he had hoped” (Source A). Using the sources and your own knowledge, to what extent do you agree with this statement?
Using the sources and your own knowledge, to what extent do you agree? [9]
Answer:Agree to a large extent: Jerusalem was not retaken and Saladin kept power; but Richard reversed the losses after Hattin, secured the coast (Acre to Jaffa) and pilgrim access, so the Latin presence survived.
Watch out: Integrate the sources with your own knowledge (Acre, Arsuf, Hattin) and reach a clear conclusion.
HISTORY PAPER 1 · 4 MAY 2026
Case study: the final stages of Muslim rule in Spain, coexistence of populations. Source E (Fernando and Isabel, the Alhambra Decree, 1492): the monarchs say that, according to the inquisitors, Jews were drawing Christians (especially conversos) away from the Catholic faith by teaching them Jewish rites, prayers, fasts, Passover and food laws; therefore they order all Jews to be expelled from their kingdoms, never to return. Source F: a painting by Pedro Berruguete (1491–1499) showing an auto-da-fé: churchmen preside from a platform while prisoners in penitential robes are led out and two condemned men are tied to stakes. Source G (Norman Roth, historian of Jewish studies, 2002): Jews generally lived harmoniously with Muslim and Christian neighbours, cooperating in science and medicine and holding high government posts; this ended with the 1492 expulsion; many conversos were sincere Christians, but jealousy and open persecution by “Old Christians” led to open conflict with “New Christians” in the mid-15th century. Source H (Paola Tartakoff, professor of history and Jewish studies, 2022): under Muslim and early Christian rule the three communities collaborated and flourished (the Alhambra, works in Arabic, Hebrew, Latin and Spanish), but coexistence was never free of tension; the 1492 expulsion drew on centuries of hatred; 40 000 to over 150 000 Jews fled; many who stayed converted; the Spanish Inquisition expanded.
(a) What, according to Source E, were the reasons to expel the Jews from the Iberian Peninsula? [3]
(b) What does Source F suggest about Christian attitudes to other religions? [2]
Answer:Any three: Jews were trying to undermine the Catholic faith; they drew Christians (conversos) away from Christianity; they taught Christians Jewish ceremonies, prayers and fasts; they gave them books and unleavened bread for Passover and taught food laws; the inquisitors and the council advised expulsion.
Answer:Two of: intolerance (non-Christians or heretics were publicly punished); religious authority was used to enforce conformity (churchmen preside); punishment was severe and public, even execution by burning, to deter others.
With reference to its origin, purpose and content, analyse the value and limitations of Source E for an historian studying Fernando and Isabel’s attitude towards the Jews in the late 15th century.
Analyse the value and limitations of Source E. [4]
Answer:Value: the monarchs’ own official words, showing their stated religious reasons. Limitation: a public justification that may hide political or economic motives and gives no Jewish view.
Compare and contrast what Sources G and H reveal about the coexistence of Christians, Jews and conversos in late 15th-century Spain.
Compare and contrast Sources G and H. [6]
Answer:Both describe real cooperation that ended in 1492 and growing hostility to conversos; G stresses harmony and the sincerity of conversos, while H stresses long-standing tension, the scale of the exodus and the Inquisition.
Using the sources and your own knowledge, examine the challenges to coexistence between Christians, Jews and conversos in the Iberian Peninsula.
Using the sources and your own knowledge, examine the challenges to coexistence. [9]
Answer:Religious intolerance (Inquisition, autos-da-fé), social jealousy and blood-purity laws, the monarchy’s push for religious unity after Granada, and economic resentment all undermined coexistence, despite earlier cooperation.
HISTORY PAPER 1 · 4 MAY 2026
Case study: Japanese expansion in East Asia (1931–1941), responses: the League of Nations and the Lytton Report. Source I (David Wen-wei Chang, political scientist, 2003): if Britain, the US and France had united to contain Japan, Japan would have withdrawn from Manchuria and the League’s authority would have been saved; the Western powers failed to uphold the Nine-Power Treaty, the Kellogg–Briand Pact and the League, and this appeasement made the Second World War unavoidable; by December 1931 the League stopped demanding Japanese withdrawal; the Lytton Commission’s warnings in 1932 were ignored and Japan recognised Manchukuo in September 1932. Source J (David G. Williamson, history teacher, 2015): the League responded cautiously and sent the Lytton Commission; without the Great Powers it could not act; Britain and the US could not use force, and the US, hit by the Depression, would only denounce Japan, as Hoover feared sanctions would provoke war; the 1932 report said Manchuria had been occupied by force and proposed Japanese withdrawal to the railway zone, a treaty, a non-aggression pact and a trade agreement; when it was adopted, Japan left the League, and only armed intervention could have removed Japan, which was unrealistic in 1933. Source K: a 1932 cartoon by Rollin Kirby in the New York World-Telegram, “The Grabber’s answer”: a rifle labelled “Japan’s plea of self-defense” spears a document titled “Lytton Report on Manchukuo”, with “Geneva” in the background and League delegates looking on. Source L (Lytton Report, 1932): restoring the old situation is no solution, but recognising the present regime (Manchukuo) is also unacceptable; a solution should respect the interests of both China and Japan, recognise Japan’s interests in Manchuria, give Manchuria wide autonomy under Chinese sovereignty, and encourage a fair commercial treaty; this might start an era of co-operation.
(a) What, according to Source L, were the principles guiding the Lytton Report? [3]
(b) What does Source K suggest about the response to the Lytton Report? [2]
Answer:Any three: compatibility with the interests of both China and Japan; recognition of Japan’s interests in Manchuria; a large measure of autonomy for Manchuria under Chinese sovereignty; an equal economic/commercial agreement between China and Japan; neither restoring the old situation nor recognising Manchukuo.
Answer:Japan rejected the report contemptuously and by force (the bayonet stabs it); Japan’s claim of “self-defence” was a pretext; the League (Geneva) was powerless to stop it.
With reference to its origin, purpose and content, analyse the value and limitations of Source L for an historian studying the League of Nations’ response to Japanese expansion in Manchuria.
Analyse the value and limitations of Source L. [4]
Answer:Value: the League’s own official, contemporary proposals, showing its cautious, compromise approach. Limitation: shows intentions, not outcomes, and is diplomatically worded.
Compare and contrast what Sources I and J reveal about the League of Nations’ response to Japanese expansion in Manchuria.
Compare and contrast Sources I and J. [6]
Answer:Both describe a weak, cautious League dependent on the Great Powers and ignored by Japan. I blames Western appeasement and claims a united front could have succeeded; J argues the powers were unable to act and force was unrealistic.
Using the sources and your own knowledge, discuss the effectiveness of the League of Nations’ response to Japanese expansion between 1931 and 1941.
Using the sources and your own knowledge, discuss the effectiveness of the League’s response. [9]
Answer:Largely ineffective: slow, no sanctions, Japan left the League and expanded further (1933, 1937); some moral value from the Lytton Report and non-recognition, but the failure weakened collective security.
The topic map groups the questions by skill. Each prescribed subject has the same pattern: a comprehension question (5 marks), an OPCVL question (4), a comparison (6) and an essay (9).
| Skill | Questions | Marks | Share of marks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evaluative essay | 3 | 27 | 38% |
| Comparing sources | 3 | 18 | 25% |
| Source comprehension | 3 | 15 | 21% |
| Source analysis (OPCVL) | 3 | 12 | 17% |
| Question | Topic | Area | Marks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prescribed subject 1: Military leaders Q1 | Outcomes of the Third Crusade and Christian–Muslim relations | Source comprehension | 5 |
| Prescribed subject 1: Military leaders Q2 | Value and limitations: Source D | Source analysis (OPCVL) | 4 |
| Prescribed subject 1: Military leaders Q3 | Compare and contrast Sources A and C | Comparing sources | 6 |
| Prescribed subject 1: Military leaders Q4 | Did Richard fail in the Middle East? | Evaluative essay | 9 |
| Prescribed subject 2: Conquest and its impact Q5 | Reasons for the expulsion and Christian attitudes | Source comprehension | 5 |
| Prescribed subject 2: Conquest and its impact Q6 | Value and limitations: Source E | Source analysis (OPCVL) | 4 |
| Prescribed subject 2: Conquest and its impact Q7 | Compare and contrast Sources G and H | Comparing sources | 6 |
| Prescribed subject 2: Conquest and its impact Q8 | Challenges to coexistence in Iberia | Evaluative essay | 9 |
| Prescribed subject 3: The move to global war Q9 | The Lytton Report and the response to it | Source comprehension | 5 |
| Prescribed subject 3: The move to global war Q10 | Value and limitations: Source L | Source analysis (OPCVL) | 4 |
| Prescribed subject 3: The move to global war Q11 | Compare and contrast Sources I and J | Comparing sources | 6 |
| Prescribed subject 3: The move to global war Q12 | Effectiveness of the League’s response, 1931–1941 | Evaluative essay | 9 |
Comprehension and OPCVL. Give separate, explicit points for “according to” questions. For OPCVL, link every value and limitation to origin, purpose or content and to the question’s enquiry.
Comparison. Write point by point: a similarity with evidence from both sources, then a difference, and so on. Avoid describing each source separately.
Essay. Plan for two minutes: list what each source says and two or three facts of your own, decide your judgement, then write a balanced argument with a clear conclusion.
Work by topic. After a first pass, redo the questions for your weakest skill in the topic map. Seeing three or four questions on the same idea from different papers is the quickest way to see what the examiners expect.
A LITTLE MORE CLARITY
Papers, marks, time zones and how to use the worked solutions.
Tell us about your needsPaper 1 (4 May 2026, afternoon, 1 hour, 24 marks) is the source-based paper for both HL and SL. Students answer four questions on one prescribed subject, using the sources in the source booklet.
Prescribed subject 1 (Military leaders: Richard I), 2 (Conquest and its impact: the end of Muslim rule in Spain) and 3 (The move to global war: the League of Nations and Manchuria). Each has full model answers to all four questions (24 marks each).
No. These are original model answers written for learners and are not published or approved by the IB. Source questions accept many valid points; the answers show strong examples.
Do not just label origin, purpose and content. Explain how each makes the source more or less valuable for the specific enquiry in the question, giving at least one value and one limitation.
Use all four sources, add accurate own knowledge (dates, events, names), build a balanced argument and finish with a clear judgement on the question.
Roughly 5 minutes reading, about 5 minutes on question 1, 8 minutes on the OPCVL question, 12 minutes on the comparison and 25 minutes on the essay.
YOUR NEXT STEP STARTS HERE
Work one to one with a tutor on source analysis, OPCVL, comparison and essay technique.